diff --git a/scripts/simplifiedUI/ui/simplifiedUI.js b/scripts/simplifiedUI/ui/simplifiedUI.js
index da37038c28..16f081fb6b 100644
--- a/scripts/simplifiedUI/ui/simplifiedUI.js
+++ b/scripts/simplifiedUI/ui/simplifiedUI.js
@@ -464,7 +464,7 @@ function onDisplayModeChanged(isHMDMode) {
 }
 
 function onToolbarVisibleChanged(isVisible, toolbarName) {
-    if (isVisible && toolbarName == TOOLBAR_NAME && Settings.getValue("simplifiedUI/keepExistingUIAndScripts", false)) {
+    if (isVisible && toolbarName == TOOLBAR_NAME && !Settings.getValue("simplifiedUI/keepExistingUIAndScripts", false)) {
         var toolbar = Toolbars.getToolbar(toolbarName);
         if (toolbar) {
             toolbar.writeProperty("visible", false);